{ "version": "source-aware-review-2", "reviewed_at": "2026-09-06", "sources": [ { "id": "horn200", "title": "Michael Horn — #200 reproduction note", "url": "https://www.theyfly.com/look-out-tree", "locator": "After photo 26: note attributed to James Deardorff describes #200 as a cropped blow-up from an electrically scanned negative on a HELL Chromograph. Wedding Cake is the next, separate section." }, { "id": "kinder-book", "title": "Gary Kinder — Light Years, technical interviews", "url": "https://rune.ws/spesBoker/LightYears_garyKinder.pdf", "locator": "Reformatted PDF pages 143–147. Eliason and Malin: qualified favorable observations, copied inputs and unresolved original-film information." }, { "id": "episode", "title": "Jorjani with Jesse Michels — public episode", "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9870s", "locator": "2:44:30–2:48:45 captured; surrounding captions through 2:49:26 reviewed. Public upload, not the differently aligned early cut." }, { "id": "catalogue", "title": "Meier photographic catalogue", "url": "https://www.futureofmankind.co.uk/Billy_Meier/Photo_Gallery", "locator": "Advocacy archive. Used to match composition and read catalogue labels; not an independent authentication." }, { "id": "photo638", "title": "Catalogue #638 — full composition", "url": "https://www.futureofmankind.co.uk/w/images/2/26/F0638.jpg", "locator": "Embedded label: Berg-Rumlikon, 14 June 1975. Camera foreground, cable loop, hill contour and object position match." }, { "id": "photo200", "title": "Catalogue #200 — detail reproduction", "url": "https://www.futureofmankind.co.uk/w/images/a/a8/Beamship.jpg", "locator": "Embedded label: Bachtelhörnli, 8 March 1976. Crown, flange and reflections match the golden insert. Date is catalogue attribution." }, { "id": "davis", "title": "Neil M. Davis — 13 March 1978 report", "url": "https://futureofmankind.info/Billy_Meier/Photo_analysis_report,_Davis,_Neil_M.,_published_in_Stevens'_1982_book,_March_1978", "locator": "Reproduced text of the report, not an inspected signed original. One copied print; preliminary qualitative finding." }, { "id": "stevens", "title": "Stevens / Dilettoso — Photo Analysis", "url": "https://theyfly.com/PDF/PhotoAnalysis.pdf", "locator": "PDF pages 6–8: enlargement of #200, Davis account and original-transparency/internegative history. A method inventory is not a per-image results sheet." }, { "id": "kinder", "title": "Gary Kinder — Open Letter, MUFON no. 228 (1987)", "url": "https://futureofmankind.co.uk/Billy_Meier/An_Open_Letter_to_the_UFO_Community,_Kinder,_Gary,_MUFON_UFO_Journal_,_No._228,_pp._3-8,_April_1987", "locator": "Technical discussion of Wally Gentleman, Michael Malin and copied-material limitations. Not Vallée’s original words." }, { "id": "vallee2014", "title": "Jacques Vallée — interview, 2014 English republication", "url": "https://openminds.tv/interview-ufo-researcher-author-jacques-vallee/", "locator": "Questions from Jean-Pierre Troadec, question 2. General Meier judgment; no numbered-image analysis or ILM wording. Translation authorised by interviewer." }, { "id": "gsw", "title": "Ground Saucer Watch — April 1980 bulletin", "url": "https://files.afu.se/Downloads/Magazines/United%20States/Ground%20Saucer%20Watch%20Bulletin%20%28Bill%20Spaulding%29/Ground%20Saucer%20Watch%20Bulletin%20-%201980%2004%20-%20April.pdf", "locator": "Printed pages 4–7 / PDF pages 5–8. Ten submitted photographs; adverse findings expressly not extended to all material." }, { "id": "swgde", "title": "SWGDE 18-I-001-2.0 — Image Authentication (3 March 2025)", "url": "https://www.swgde.org/documents/published-complete-listing/18-i-001-best-practices-for-image-authentication/", "locator": "Sections 2 and 5–9: task-relevant complexity/access, methods, scope, uncertainty and bias. No endorsement of this site or our editorial points." }, { "id": "icd203", "title": "ODNI ICD 203 — Analytic Standards (2015, as amended)", "url": "https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/ICD/ICD-203.pdf", "locator": "D.6.e(1–4): source access, validation and expertise; explicit uncertainty and alternatives. Our point weights are not an ODNI rubric." } ], "scope": "Pilot for this passage and displayed materials only. Legacy CCS and other records have not been globally rescored.", "reviews": [ { "id": "jorjani-meier-photos", "targets": [ "beings/nordic", "people/jason-jorjani", "crafts/flying-saucer-disc" ], "title": "The Meier photographs: follow the actual material", "summary": "Eleven visual excerpts from the Jorjani episode, two catalogue matches and a source-by-source review of the photographic arguments. Specificity receives research-utility credit; photographic authentication is evaluated separately.", "subject": "Jason Reza Jorjani — the Meier-photo passage, not a universal personal credibility rating", "utility": { "identity": { "value": 2, "reason": "The named speaker and public passage are directly identifiable. This is traceable testimony, not anonymous circulation.", "source_ids": [ "episode" ] }, "specificity": { "value": 2, "reason": "Named experts, a technological-resources claim and a historical period create concrete follow-up questions.", "source_ids": [ "episode" ] }, "context": { "value": 2, "reason": "The passage connects the contact narrative, photographic material and earlier technical discussion. Contextual detail is credited for research usefulness, not assumed to be accurate in every respect.", "source_ids": [ "episode" ] }, "traceability": { "value": 1, "reason": "There are named leads, but no exact Vallée locator or numbered list of his supposedly best photographs.", "source_ids": [ "episode" ] }, "access": { "value": 0, "reason": "This passage supplies a second-hand assessment; it does not establish Jorjani’s direct examination of the camera-originals. Zero here means no demonstrated direct access in this passage, not dishonesty.", "source_ids": [ "episode" ] }, "calibration": { "value": 1, "reason": "The possibility of fabrication is acknowledged, but the demanding-effects claim is not scoped to identified inputs or controlled tests.", "source_ids": [ "episode" ] } }, "track_record": { "state": "unknown", "reason": "No calibrated historical-accuracy audit of Jorjani was performed. No positive or negative lifetime reliability score is assigned." }, "checks": { "original_available": { "state": "unknown", "reason": "We hold a browser-playback derivative, not the camera-originals. Historical reports of original slides do not establish current custody." }, "custody_documented": { "state": "unknown", "reason": "Not established for the displayed set; inspect individual items." }, "analysis_matched": { "state": "unknown", "reason": "Historical favorable and adverse analyses were acquired, but no complete mapping connects their tested inputs to these displayed items." }, "methods_available": { "state": "unknown", "reason": "Not established for the displayed set; inspect individual items." }, "independent_replication": { "state": "unknown", "reason": "Not established for the displayed set; inspect individual items." }, "event_link": { "state": "unknown", "reason": "Not established for the displayed set; inspect individual items." } }, "input_type": "derivative", "examination_outcome": "unresolved", "observations": [], "computed": { "version": "source-aware-review-2", "utility_points": 8, "utility_max": 12, "utility_display": "8/12 editorial points", "utility_unknown": [], "utility_is_probability": false, "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item", "verified_independent_origins": 0, "event_link": "Event link not established by this review", "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm", "reviewed_checks": 0 } } ] }