{
  "version": "jorjani-photo-review-1",
  "reviewed_at": "2026-09-06",
  "scope": {
    "video": "EzPmG_7WhXc",
    "start_s": 9870,
    "end_s": 10125.93942,
    "panels": 11,
    "material_panels": 6,
    "context_panels": 5,
    "catalogue_matches": 2,
    "count_note": "Presentation panels, not eleven independent photos or witnesses. One panel contains two portraits; two are archival-video excerpts. Crops, copies and reposts do not add independent origins."
  },
  "acquisition": {
    "video": "EzPmG_7WhXc",
    "capture_start": 9870,
    "capture_stop": 10125.93942,
    "capture_sha256": "7f945285c1e48dec3e4334a1c42184c5bb309944b0f04b0f912970a5f0bea56d",
    "capture_method": "Public browser playback, captureStream/MediaRecorder. Not the source file or a camera-original. Approximate source time ±1 second.",
    "rights": "American Alchemy/Jesse Michels and underlying image rightsholders retain their rights. Limited excerpts for item-specific research commentary; not CC BY."
  },
  "sources": [
    {
      "id": "horn200",
      "title": "Michael Horn — #200 reproduction note",
      "url": "https://www.theyfly.com/look-out-tree",
      "locator": "After photo 26: note attributed to James Deardorff describes #200 as a cropped blow-up from an electrically scanned negative on a HELL Chromograph. Wedding Cake is the next, separate section."
    },
    {
      "id": "kinder-book",
      "title": "Gary Kinder — Light Years, technical interviews",
      "url": "https://rune.ws/spesBoker/LightYears_garyKinder.pdf",
      "locator": "Reformatted PDF pages 143–147. Eliason and Malin: qualified favorable observations, copied inputs and unresolved original-film information."
    },
    {
      "id": "episode",
      "title": "Jorjani with Jesse Michels — public episode",
      "url": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9870s",
      "locator": "2:44:30–2:48:45 captured; surrounding captions through 2:49:26 reviewed. Public upload, not the differently aligned early cut."
    },
    {
      "id": "catalogue",
      "title": "Meier photographic catalogue",
      "url": "https://www.futureofmankind.co.uk/Billy_Meier/Photo_Gallery",
      "locator": "Advocacy archive. Used to match composition and read catalogue labels; not an independent authentication."
    },
    {
      "id": "photo638",
      "title": "Catalogue #638 — full composition",
      "url": "https://www.futureofmankind.co.uk/w/images/2/26/F0638.jpg",
      "locator": "Embedded label: Berg-Rumlikon, 14 June 1975. Camera foreground, cable loop, hill contour and object position match."
    },
    {
      "id": "photo200",
      "title": "Catalogue #200 — detail reproduction",
      "url": "https://www.futureofmankind.co.uk/w/images/a/a8/Beamship.jpg",
      "locator": "Embedded label: Bachtelhörnli, 8 March 1976. Crown, flange and reflections match the golden insert. Date is catalogue attribution."
    },
    {
      "id": "davis",
      "title": "Neil M. Davis — 13 March 1978 report",
      "url": "https://futureofmankind.info/Billy_Meier/Photo_analysis_report,_Davis,_Neil_M.,_published_in_Stevens'_1982_book,_March_1978",
      "locator": "Reproduced text of the report, not an inspected signed original. One copied print; preliminary qualitative finding."
    },
    {
      "id": "stevens",
      "title": "Stevens / Dilettoso — Photo Analysis",
      "url": "https://theyfly.com/PDF/PhotoAnalysis.pdf",
      "locator": "PDF pages 6–8: enlargement of #200, Davis account and original-transparency/internegative history. A method inventory is not a per-image results sheet."
    },
    {
      "id": "kinder",
      "title": "Gary Kinder — Open Letter, MUFON no. 228 (1987)",
      "url": "https://futureofmankind.co.uk/Billy_Meier/An_Open_Letter_to_the_UFO_Community,_Kinder,_Gary,_MUFON_UFO_Journal_,_No._228,_pp._3-8,_April_1987",
      "locator": "Technical discussion of Wally Gentleman, Michael Malin and copied-material limitations. Not Vallée’s original words."
    },
    {
      "id": "vallee2014",
      "title": "Jacques Vallée — interview, 2014 English republication",
      "url": "https://openminds.tv/interview-ufo-researcher-author-jacques-vallee/",
      "locator": "Questions from Jean-Pierre Troadec, question 2. General Meier judgment; no numbered-image analysis or ILM wording. Translation authorised by interviewer."
    },
    {
      "id": "gsw",
      "title": "Ground Saucer Watch — April 1980 bulletin",
      "url": "https://files.afu.se/Downloads/Magazines/United%20States/Ground%20Saucer%20Watch%20Bulletin%20%28Bill%20Spaulding%29/Ground%20Saucer%20Watch%20Bulletin%20-%201980%2004%20-%20April.pdf",
      "locator": "Printed pages 4–7 / PDF pages 5–8. Ten submitted photographs; adverse findings expressly not extended to all material."
    },
    {
      "id": "swgde",
      "title": "SWGDE 18-I-001-2.0 — Image Authentication (3 March 2025)",
      "url": "https://www.swgde.org/documents/published-complete-listing/18-i-001-best-practices-for-image-authentication/",
      "locator": "Sections 2 and 5–9: task-relevant complexity/access, methods, scope, uncertainty and bias. No endorsement of this site or our editorial points."
    },
    {
      "id": "icd203",
      "title": "ODNI ICD 203 — Analytic Standards (2015, as amended)",
      "url": "https://www.dni.gov/files/documents/ICD/ICD-203.pdf",
      "locator": "D.6.e(1–4): source access, validation and expertise; explicit uncertainty and alternatives. Our point weights are not an ODNI rubric."
    }
  ],
  "items": [
    {
      "id": "garden-portrait",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/garden-portrait.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 40,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9910,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "349dfdb62b0f57584622c09594e278be2fefee5c21f5c84ca767d9b28730c946",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "context",
      "title": "Meier in a garden",
      "kind": "Portrait insert",
      "visible": "A white-bearded man presented in the episode as Billy Meier, standing among plants.",
      "value": "Biographical context, not an image of a reported occupant.",
      "limit": "The underlying portrait photographer, date and original file were not established.",
      "origin_id": "episode-context-garden",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9910s",
      "display_time": "2:45:10",
      "image_identity": "unresolved",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:garden-portrait",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "paired-portraits",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/paired-portraits.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 50,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9920,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "2ab2cd1aa0361ea8f72a2f14befabbf29b3e980d80c6cda252a3e01c7701a599",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "context",
      "title": "Two archival portraits",
      "kind": "Two photos in one edited panel",
      "visible": "Two black-and-white portraits appear side by side. Their pairing is the episode’s presentation.",
      "value": "The panel preserves both pictures instead of counting each crop as a new witness.",
      "limit": "Original photographer, date and contextual caption remain to be acquired.",
      "origin_id": "episode-context-pair",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9920s",
      "display_time": "2:45:20",
      "image_identity": "unresolved",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:paired-portraits",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "group-portrait",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/group-portrait.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 55,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9925,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "0631bf7941e31d378d3440ffaeb1df4f59d82305e8cd4de8fb06dd40d0fc8166",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "context",
      "title": "Archival group photograph",
      "kind": "Portrait insert",
      "visible": "Three people are shown in a black-and-white group photograph.",
      "value": "The visual is retained as context for the biography being discussed.",
      "limit": "We do not infer the other people’s identities, rank or relationship from appearance.",
      "origin_id": "episode-context-group",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9925s",
      "display_time": "2:45:25",
      "image_identity": "unresolved",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:group-portrait",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "seated-portrait",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/seated-portrait.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 71,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9941,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "af42968cd3bfb9067279690b95612438219034d46d976d6f2038a78b4f38f97d",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "context",
      "title": "Colour portrait",
      "kind": "Portrait insert",
      "visible": "A bearded man wearing glasses is presented during the discussion of Meier.",
      "value": "This is a biographical illustration used by the programme.",
      "limit": "Its presence does not independently corroborate the accompanying life-history claims.",
      "origin_id": "episode-context-colour",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9941s",
      "display_time": "2:45:41",
      "image_identity": "unresolved",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:seated-portrait",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "camera-footage",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/camera-footage.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 105,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9975,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "a624641210a03647f5e6a19929046f06a3929d77b597a63e88bead4e650fd51b",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "context",
      "title": "Handling a camera",
      "kind": "Frame from archival moving footage",
      "visible": "Meier is shown handling a camera in an archival video insert.",
      "value": "Potentially useful for identifying equipment and locating the original demonstration.",
      "limit": "An edited demonstration is not an unbroken recording of the reported craft encounter. The original film source is unresolved.",
      "origin_id": "episode-camera-demo",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9975s",
      "display_time": "2:46:15",
      "image_identity": "unresolved",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:camera-footage",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "print-in-hands",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/print-in-hands.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 108,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9978,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "c818b4f3b00ea345888aee3f899b87488808351f247ae8403b089e3ce0825afd",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "material",
      "title": "A print compared outdoors",
      "kind": "Frame from archival moving footage",
      "visible": "Hands hold a photographic print in an outdoor setting.",
      "value": "A lead for reconstructing how investigators compared an image with a scene.",
      "limit": "The print’s catalogue number and the date and location of this comparison have not been securely matched.",
      "origin_id": "episode-print-comparison",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9978s",
      "display_time": "2:46:18",
      "image_identity": "unresolved",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:print-in-hands",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "three-saucers",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/three-saucers.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 112,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9982,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "849231dcfbe1c135253ed9ee4878f897a5b7b0f00d035e775849ca623bb229c8",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "material",
      "title": "Forms above a valley",
      "kind": "Displayed craft image",
      "visible": "Two dark forms are distinguishable above a rural landscape. The broadcast reframes the scene.",
      "value": "The landscape and relative positions offer features for finding the original sequence.",
      "limit": "A zoom in the programme is not evidence that the objects moved. Exact catalogue number or film reel remains unresolved.",
      "origin_id": "meier-valley-unresolved",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode",
        "catalogue"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9982s",
      "display_time": "2:46:22",
      "image_identity": "unresolved",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:three-saucers",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "smooth-closeup",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/smooth-closeup.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 124.6,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9994.6,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "bc9bef4104aa47176ea33fba40b6d359711d255617e6c39755b5d9a71e572968",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "material",
      "title": "Smooth, stepped dome",
      "kind": "Displayed close-up",
      "visible": "A close-up shows a smooth disc and concentric steps on its dome.",
      "value": "The next insert gives wider scene context and a possible route back to the original.",
      "limit": "This may be a crop of #638, but object-only similarity is insufficient to assert that identity. It is not counted as an independent observation.",
      "origin_id": "meier-smooth-unresolved",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode",
        "photo638"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9994s",
      "display_time": "2:46:34",
      "image_identity": "unresolved",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:smooth-closeup",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "camera-foreground",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/camera-foreground.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 126.8,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9996.8,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "6e9bf7be8412eaad6657bab68e72ef81b2cbcda655b30fa40737b9f08ce8b684",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "material",
      "title": "The camera in the foreground",
      "kind": "Catalogue composition matched · #638",
      "visible": "A camera or related apparatus, with a silver top and cable loop, occupies the foreground; a small disc is above the distant landscape.",
      "value": "The composition matches the labelled #638 reproduction. It is equipment, not a conifer: tree-occlusion arguments cannot be applied to this foreground object.",
      "limit": "The catalogue label is Berg-Rumlikon, 14 June 1975. Matching the reproduction does not establish object size, distance or the integrity of the camera-original.",
      "origin_id": "meier-photo-638",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode",
        "photo638"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9996s",
      "display_time": "2:46:36",
      "image_identity": "catalogue_composition_matched",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:camera-foreground",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "dark-closeup",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/dark-closeup.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 129,
      "source_seconds_approx": 9999,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "0a0c65e313e272c1197b411bb78bef47ba51b71c5fcc5327370b30e39e80230a",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "material",
      "title": "Dark, elaborate disc",
      "kind": "Displayed close-up",
      "visible": "A dark disc has a broad rim, a bluish upper section and an irregular crown.",
      "value": "Distinctive structure allows a targeted catalogue comparison instead of a generic saucer illustration.",
      "limit": "The image number remains unresolved in this edition. It must not inherit an analysis of a superficially similar photograph.",
      "origin_id": "meier-dark-unresolved",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode",
        "catalogue"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=9999s",
      "display_time": "2:46:39",
      "image_identity": "unresolved",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:dark-closeup",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "golden-closeup",
      "image": "/photo-review/images/golden-closeup.jpg",
      "capture_offset_s": 135,
      "source_seconds_approx": 10005,
      "timestamp_tolerance_s": 1,
      "sha256": "535841b432184cd73b70550b3f1127b8f13760fa85994546755422cd36d4875f",
      "modification": "Full video composition retained; resized to 720×406 JPEG. No crop, enhancement, restoration or generated detail.",
      "group": "material",
      "title": "The golden close-up",
      "kind": "Catalogue composition matched · #200",
      "visible": "A gold-toned disc has a raised crown and broad flange. The crown, reflections and edge structure match the #200 detail reproduction.",
      "value": "The catalogue identity creates a specific acquisition target: #200 and its enlargement/copying history. Horn’s page attributes to Deardorff an electronic-scan and cropped-enlargement history; sharp edges must be interpreted with that processing in mind.",
      "limit": "The label gives Bachtelhörnli, 8 March 1976; the date is a catalogue attribution, not independently verified. It is not labelled Wedding Cake. A processed reproduction is not a camera-original.",
      "origin_id": "meier-photo-200",
      "independent_origin_verified": false,
      "source_ids": [
        "episode",
        "photo200",
        "stevens",
        "horn200"
      ],
      "source": "https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzPmG_7WhXc&t=10005s",
      "display_time": "2:46:45",
      "image_identity": "catalogue_composition_matched",
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "event_link": "This excerpt does not establish a Nordic occupant or ET origin.",
      "assessment_input": {
        "artifact_id": "EzPmG_7WhXc:frame:golden-closeup",
        "input_type": "derivative",
        "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
        "checks": {},
        "observations": []
      },
      "assessment": {
        "version": "source-aware-review-2",
        "utility_points": 0,
        "utility_max": 12,
        "utility_display": "Not assessed",
        "utility_unknown": [
          "identity",
          "specificity",
          "context",
          "traceability",
          "access",
          "calibration"
        ],
        "utility_is_probability": false,
        "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
        "verified_independent_origins": 0,
        "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
        "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
        "reviewed_checks": 0
      }
    }
  ],
  "review": {
    "id": "jorjani-meier-photos",
    "targets": [
      "beings/nordic",
      "people/jason-jorjani",
      "crafts/flying-saucer-disc"
    ],
    "title": "The Meier photographs: follow the actual material",
    "summary": "Eleven visual excerpts from the Jorjani episode, two catalogue matches and a source-by-source review of the photographic arguments. Specificity receives research-utility credit; photographic authentication is evaluated separately.",
    "subject": "Jason Reza Jorjani — the Meier-photo passage, not a universal personal credibility rating",
    "utility": {
      "identity": {
        "value": 2,
        "reason": "The named speaker and public passage are directly identifiable. This is traceable testimony, not anonymous circulation.",
        "source_ids": [
          "episode"
        ]
      },
      "specificity": {
        "value": 2,
        "reason": "Named experts, a technological-resources claim and a historical period create concrete follow-up questions.",
        "source_ids": [
          "episode"
        ]
      },
      "context": {
        "value": 2,
        "reason": "The passage connects the contact narrative, photographic material and earlier technical discussion. Contextual detail is credited for research usefulness, not assumed to be accurate in every respect.",
        "source_ids": [
          "episode"
        ]
      },
      "traceability": {
        "value": 1,
        "reason": "There are named leads, but no exact Vallée locator or numbered list of his supposedly best photographs.",
        "source_ids": [
          "episode"
        ]
      },
      "access": {
        "value": 0,
        "reason": "This passage supplies a second-hand assessment; it does not establish Jorjani’s direct examination of the camera-originals. Zero here means no demonstrated direct access in this passage, not dishonesty.",
        "source_ids": [
          "episode"
        ]
      },
      "calibration": {
        "value": 1,
        "reason": "The possibility of fabrication is acknowledged, but the demanding-effects claim is not scoped to identified inputs or controlled tests.",
        "source_ids": [
          "episode"
        ]
      }
    },
    "track_record": {
      "state": "unknown",
      "reason": "No calibrated historical-accuracy audit of Jorjani was performed. No positive or negative lifetime reliability score is assigned."
    },
    "checks": {
      "original_available": {
        "state": "unknown",
        "reason": "We hold a browser-playback derivative, not the camera-originals. Historical reports of original slides do not establish current custody."
      },
      "custody_documented": {
        "state": "unknown",
        "reason": "Not established for the displayed set; inspect individual items."
      },
      "analysis_matched": {
        "state": "unknown",
        "reason": "Historical favorable and adverse analyses were acquired, but no complete mapping connects their tested inputs to these displayed items."
      },
      "methods_available": {
        "state": "unknown",
        "reason": "Not established for the displayed set; inspect individual items."
      },
      "independent_replication": {
        "state": "unknown",
        "reason": "Not established for the displayed set; inspect individual items."
      },
      "event_link": {
        "state": "unknown",
        "reason": "Not established for the displayed set; inspect individual items."
      }
    },
    "input_type": "derivative",
    "examination_outcome": "unresolved",
    "observations": [],
    "computed": {
      "version": "source-aware-review-2",
      "utility_points": 8,
      "utility_max": 12,
      "utility_display": "8/12 editorial points",
      "utility_unknown": [],
      "utility_is_probability": false,
      "authenticity": "Authentication unresolved for this item",
      "verified_independent_origins": 0,
      "event_link": "Event link not established by this review",
      "origin_conclusion": "Not assessed by this algorithm",
      "reviewed_checks": 0
    }
  },
  "verification": {
    "audio": "Existing captions compared with a new local Whisper small.en pass on the bounded captured audio. Names and ILM remain machine-transcription-sensitive; prose paraphrases rather than certifies verbatim speech.",
    "limitations": "A browser capture includes playback compression and a minor initial audio decode warning. No original film, independent laboratory authentication, full-episode visual inventory or ET-probability calculation."
  }
}